February 13, 2023

Wild Cutthroat Trout Persevere on the Saanich Peninsula

– Thanks to a lot of great local stewardship efforts!

 

Urban cutthroat trout

Coastal cutthroat trout could be considered the aquatic equivalent of the “canary in the coal mine” when it comes to small-stream health. Like other salmonids (trout and salmon), these fish have specific habitat requirements such as clean, cool, and well-oxygenated water. However, they spend more time, if not their whole lives in freshwater. Cutthroat are also found in much smaller streams than some other salmon and trout; these streams are often not recognized, mapped, or protected as important fish habitat. Cutthroat populations are also much smaller than those of other salmonids – sometimes only a handful of adults populate a small stream, even for populations considered healthy. 

Cutthroat trout have never attracted the attention that other Pacific salmon have over the decades. They don’t support any commercial fisheries; they are smaller-bodied and fewer in number. However, they have significant cultural and ecosystem value. And as many anglers know, they provide excellent stream, lake, and estuarine (marine) recreational fishing in many areas on the coast. Unfortunately, the lower profile of this species makes it vulnerable to ongoing, cumulative human impacts on the habitat.

Southern Vancouver Island’s Saanich Peninsula is home to many small streams that once did (and often still do) support wild cutthroat populations. Depending on the stream, different “ecotypes” of cutthroat might be present, including searun (anadromous) fish that spend time in the ocean feeding, and resident fish that spend their lives in fresh water. Searun fish tend to be larger and often the target of fly fishers, while resident fish may range in size but are generally smaller (though not always the case in larger lakes on the Island and elsewhere where resident fish grow to impressive sizes). Most streams on the peninsula empty into the ocean, but some have natural or man-made barriers (e.g., waterfalls or culverts) that prevent fish from migrating upstream. Cutthroat have been documented above these barriers as residents in some streams. In other cases, cut-off access reduces habitat options, and they are either trapped upstream or can no longer move upstream to spawn. 

Local restoration activities

It may come as a surprise for some to learn that conservation efforts have been underway in streams on the Saanich Peninsula for over half a century. Now, several stewardship groups in and around Greater Victoria are taking steps to improve the awareness and protection of wild cutthroat trout and their habitats on the peninsula. The Freshwater Fisheries Society of BC is proud to have funded recent stewardship efforts targeting cutthroat streams. Since 2019, we have maintained the Native Trout Stewardship Initiative (NTSI). Stewardship groups can use these funds to support on-the-ground restoration activities, and as leverage to acquire funds from other sources to undertake larger-scale projects.

Streams involved

In 2019, a consortium of groups – including the Victoria Golden Rods and Reels, Coastal Collaborative Sciences (CSS), Peninsula Streams and Shorelines (PSS), and Esquimalt Anglers – came together to establish the Portage Inlet Cutthroat Initiative (PICI), supported by the NTSI. This initiative aims to create a long-term strategy for cutthroat populations in the inlet. Portage Inlet searun cutthroat trout were once trophy-sized fish. While still caught by avid catch-and-release fly fishers in the Gorge Waterway and Victoria harbour, the fish are now much smaller.

Activities to date include assessment and restoration activities in the Colquitz and Craigflower creeks, and funding from various sources has increased significantly. These two creeks have been heavily impacted over time by urban, agricultural, and industrial development in the Greater Victoria region. Incredibly, both cutthroat and coho still persist in these watersheds. Significant progress has been made in these streams, but work is ongoing to continue cleaning them up, to assess populations, and monitor water quality. It should be noted that all these efforts also benefit other native species in the system, like coho.


Fish population assessment on Craigflower Creek.


Success – healthy juvenile cutthroat!

Peninsula Streams and Shorelines (PSS) has been heavily involved in local stream restoration for over 20 years. This grassroots group is now a key stewardship leader in the region, taking on increasingly large projects that benefit cutthroat, coho, and other fishes, as well as stream and wetland health in general.  Often this is in collaboration with other non-governmental organizations like CSS, and local stewardship groups that they help create. Over the past three years, PSS has collaborated with the PICI in efforts to recover highly degraded sections of Colquitz Creek, targeting the “loved-to-death” Copley Park in partnership with the District of Saanich. Specifically, PSS addressed several eroded sections of stream bank and stream beds; fenced off sections of the stream from foot and dog traffic; created riffle areas critical for juvenile and spawning cutthroat and coho; and replanted areas with native vegetation. Already, fish have been observed using these restored sections. PSS has now expanded its efforts to two more cutthroat streams on the peninsula, including Hagan-Graham and Tetayut creeks. 


Restored section of Colquitz Creek in Copley Park. Note the water riffle habitat and vegetated banks.


Colquitz Creek fish-counting fence.


Example of video clip from November 2022 showing large cutthroat trout passing through the Colquitz Fish Fence that confirm significant numbers of fish in the system (clips provided by Dorothy Chambers).

Hagan-Graham, one of the largest watersheds on the peninsula, empties into Patricia Bay. This stream system has suffered a multitude of impacts from industry and agriculture, including pollution and contamination, loss of wetlands, stream-straightening to create ditches, and land clearing. PSS – in partnership with the Tsartlip First Nation, the District of Central Saanich, and other groups – is now in the process of restoring key sections of the lower watershed, and NTSI funds have contributed to these efforts. Of interest, since the system has a 10-metre-high waterfall where it empties into the ocean, the only salmonids in the system are resident cutthroat. Incredibly, fish like the one pictured below can be found here!


A beautiful specimen of a Hagan Creek resident cutthroat found above the waterfall (photo credit: Ian Bruce).


Waterfall barrier on Hagan Creek.

Incredibly productive Tetayut (Sandhill) Creek is one of the few key producers of searun cutthroat trout on southern Vancouver Island – a fact many of the local fly fishers are well aware of. Provincial fisheries have shown that this little stream can produce more juvenile cutthroat per square metre than almost any other stream assessed in B.C.

The creek has benefitted in the past from restoration efforts via the Haig-Brown Fly Fishing Association in partnership with provincial fisheries, but it still suffers some challenges. Historic restoration work included the first-ever-installed groundwater pumping station designed to offset water diversions in the summer and improve freshwater survival of juvenile cutthroat trout.

Tetayut Creek flows under the Patricia Bay Highway (Hwy 17) before emptying into Bazan Bay on the east side of the peninsula. Intact habitat for cutthroat can be found on the Heritage Acres property downstream of the highway. In 2018, PSS – in a partnership with the Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure and other groups – restored fish passage through a highway culvert (whose outlet had become perched high and dry due to scouring during high stream flows), reconnecting cutthroat to two more kilometres of habitat upstream. Given Tetayut Creek’s provincial value as a cutthroat stream, PSS hopes to continue monitoring and assessment here.


Haig-Brown Fly Fishing Association outing on Bazan Bay circa late 1970s (photo credit: Ron Ptolemy).


A large female searun cutthroat trout caught at Bazan Bay on September 12, 1975. The mature fish was 52 centimetres long and weighed 1.6 kilograms. It was feeding on Nerius worms and blennies. In the distant past, larger specimens have been documented up to 73 centimetres in length, and weighing 4.5 kilograms. The saltwater daily harvest limit was 12 fish at this time! (photo credit: Ron Ptolemy).

PSS has also been involved in restoring a cutthroat presence to several other peninsula streams including Chalet Creek, Kelset (Reay) Creek with the Sidney Anglers Association and Victoria Airport Authority, and Ten Ten Creek with the Tseycum First Nations and VAA. Forty years ago, all of these streams had lost their cutthroat populations. 

It has been exciting to see these initiatives get off the ground adding to earlier efforts, and even more so to see cutthroat now using restored areas. It is hoped that these projects continue to gain momentum and elevate the profile of cutthroat trout in the region as a special species from both cultural and environmental perspectives. Ongoing collaboration among all levels of government and stewardship groups is critical to building on these achievements.


Collaboration! Freshwater Fisheries Society of BC site-visit on Hagan-Graham Creek with PSS, World Fisheries Trust, and provincial staff.

Important to note: Angling regulations

Angling regulations for cutthroat trout on Vancouver Island are restricted to catch and release of all wild cutthroat caught in streams and rivers. At present, some streams – like Colquitz and Craigflower – are closed to all fishing. Please refer to the current synopsis to confirm any stream-specific regulations, including closures and gear restrictions, and updated regulation changes.

Want more information?

The Freshwater Fisheries Society of BC is continuing the support of local stewardship efforts, such as those described above, via the NTSI program. We expect to fund several more excellent watershed-based projects in the upcoming year through this initiative. If you are interested in learning more above these projects or the NTSI program, please contact Sue Pollard.

Contacts for the various stewardship groups involved in these projects can be found here:

‚ÄčAuthor: Sue Pollard, Freshwater Fisheries Society of BC